| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Andrew Fogarty | ||
| — |
| Branson Ashworth WYO2nd |
| Demetrius Romero UVU | — | Bryce Steiert UNI3rd |
| Demetrius Romero UVU | — | Andrew Fogarty NDSU1st |
| Medal Round | ||
| Bryce Steiert UNI3rd | — | — |
| Joe Smith OKST5th | — | Logan Schumacher ISU6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Bryce Steiert UNI | — | Logan Schumacher ISU |
| Branson Ashworth WYO | — | Joe Smith OKST |
| Semifinal | ||
| Branson Ashworth WYO | — | Logan Schumacher ISU |
| Andrew Fogarty NDSU | — | Nick Kiussis WVU |
| Bryce Steiert UNI | — | Isaiah Hokit California State University, Fresno |
| Demetrius Romero UVU | — | Joe Smith OKST |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Logan Schumacher ISU | — | Jacoby Ward AF |
| Joe Smith OKST | — | Isaiah Hokit California State University, Fresno |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Jacoby Ward AF | — | Nick Kiussis WVU |
| Logan Schumacher ISU | — | Macoy Flanagan UNCO |
| Joe Smith OKST | — | Jeremy Thomas OKLA |
| Isaiah Hokit California State University, Fresno | — | Logan Peterson SDSU |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Logan Schumacher ISU | — | Jeremy Thomas OKLA |
| Andrew Fogarty NDSU | — | Logan Peterson SDSU |
| Isaiah Hokit California State University, Fresno | — | Jacoby Ward AF |
| Joe Smith OKST | — | Macoy Flanagan UNCO |