| Round of 32 | ||
| Demetrius Thomas PITT | PIN | Edgar Ruano CLAR |
| Billy Bolia KENT | DEC 5-3 | John Barlow Kutztown University |
| Bishop McCoy Unattached | DEC 13-6 | Jack Trautman III Unattached |
| Spencer Berthold KENT | DEC 5-4 | Isaac Reid Unattached |
| Alex Nicholas PSU | TF 15-0 | Gabriel Pickett GWU |
| Jarrett Walters Unattached | DEC 9-7 | Tyler Oliver PITT-J |
| Devin Uzelac Wheeling Jesuit University | PIN | Willie Bivens III CLAR |
| Jake Koser Naval Academy Prep School | PIN | Collin Kelly Cleveland State University |
| Jake Evans Waynesburg University | DEC 13-6 | Brylee Shumaker CLAR |
| Zach Bruce PITT | DEC 5-2 | Michael Wolfgram Unattached |