| Cons. Round 3 |
| Sam Martino Cavalier Wrestling Club | — | Anthony Cefolo Broncs Wrestling Club |
| Daniel Murphy IOWA | 7-1 | Ryan Pomrinca Lehigh Valley WC |
| Garrett Clifford DCAC | 14-7 | Bradley Bihler Buffalo RTC |
| Gannon Volk Minnesota Storm | 13-8 | Nathan Limmex Boilermaker RTC |
| Dominic Giannangeli Nittany Lion Wrestling Club | 10-0 | Jwan Britton MSU |
| Noah Teaney Sooner Wrestling Club | 10-0 | William Kui New York City Regional Training Center |
| Evan Cheek NEORTC | 8-8 | Jonathan Ryan CAMP |
| Brett Gage Branson BC Brawler | 12-0 | Russell Rohlfing CSUB |
| Michael Magaldo | 12-1 | Cory Crooks ASU Wrestling |
| Robert Mason Unattached | 5-2 | Robert Rizzolino Wolfpack Wrestling Club |
| Collin Glorioso Mat-Town USA | 9-9 | Patrick Quinlan Lancaster Alliance Wrestling |
| Alex Madrigal Virginia Beach Regional Training Center | 10-0 | Kizhan Clarke DCAC |
| Luke Karam Lehigh Valley WC | 10-0 | Nate Hagan Edinboro Regional Training Center |
| Mitch Bengtson Bison Wrestling Club | 10-0 | Timothy Rooney Golden Pride Wrestling Club |
| JP Ascolese New York City Regional Training Center | 15-10 | James Pawelski New England RTC |
| Brendan Fitzgerald | 2-2 | Austin Nash Boilermaker RTC |
