| Round of 32 |
| Brad Laughlin ARMY | DEC 4-3 | Eric Fasnacht BUFF |
| Jon Jay Chavez Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | TF 16-1 | Owen Jones NYU |
| James Murdoch NYU | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Travis Ahrens US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Aidan Monteverdi BING | MAJ DEC 18-4 | Jackson Bell SUNY Brockport |
| Nick Velez Ithaca College | DEC 11-5 | Owen Brown ARMY |
| Jonah Barley COR | PIN | Jaelen Jean Niagara County Community College |
| Alec Corrao Ithaca College | PIN | Vincent Buscemi Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Foster Karmon COR | DEC 7-2 | Noah Grover BUFF |
| Troy Keller Niagara County Community College | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Jakob Brindley Finger Lakes Wrestling Club |
| Casey Provost SUNY Brockport | TF 22-7 | Clayton Porcaro ARMY |
| John Stawinski Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Matt Shields SUNY Ulster |
| Matt Russo COR | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Richard Mills SUNY Brockport |
| Grant Fetchet COLU | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Jakob Warner Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Colby Hall Rochester Institute of Technology | PIN | Jose Cintron SUNY Sullivan |
| Jackson Mordente Long Island University | DEC 11-8 | Kai Rodgers US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Sam Buck US Merchant Marine Academy | PIN | Devin Lezzoni Oneonta State |
