| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Donald Donnelly COLU | DEC 11-4 | Cameron Page Jamestown Community College |
| Joe Lupisella Rochester Institute of Technology | PIN | Zachary Schmitt Farmingdale State College |
| Michael Abidin Nassau Community College | DEC 12-5 | Stephen Illicete Farmingdale State College |
| Armando Arce Jamestown Community College | PIN | Leon Paul Farmingdale State College |
| Jake Lanning BUFF | PIN | Jaried Buxton COR |
| Casey Cornett ARMY | PIN | Nik Hansen Ithaca College |
| Andrew Berreyesa Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Alexander Melikian BING |
| Ryan Marszal Oneonta State | DEC 4-2 | Cameron Caldarelli BUFF |