| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Mike Dusold Nassau Community College | DEC 17-10 | Barry Hart Hunter College |
| Erik Beshada US Merchant Marine Academy | TF 17-0 | William Heine Hunter College |
| Christian Willoughby US Merchant Marine Academy | DEC 11-4 | Dan Lucey Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Zach Colgan Niagara County Community College | DEC 7-2 | Wonsik Kim Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Coty Lutz Rochester Institute of Technology | PIN | Sheraz Noory Hunter College |
| Austin Scheer Oneonta State | PIN | Shawn Soneja NYU |
| Anthony Fano Ithaca College | DEC 2-0 | Grant Fetchet COLU |
| Matt Russo COR | DEC 7-5 | Bryan Mongiello SUNY Brockport |