| Round of 32 |
| Trent Holyfield Davenport University | MAJ DEC 15-6 | Larry Prade Missouri Baptist University |
| Gage Stallworth University of Central Oklahoma | DEC 7-1 | Saul Ortiz Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| Daniel Rittell Williams Baptist College | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Austin Vannatter Davenport University |
| Jacob Sherill Ouachita Baptist University | PIN | Christian Garcia Bethany College |
| Dalton Tipton Missouri Valley College | PIN | Kristian Aguirre Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Ryan Whittle Williams Baptist College | DEC 9-6 | Dan Andress NIU |
| Carver James ILL | TF 18-3 | Blake Joiner Grand View University |
| Taylor Watkins MIZZ | TF 17-1 | Joshua Jacobson University of Central Oklahoma |
| Joey Gunther IOWA | DEC 3-2 | Qian'te Wagner McKendree University |
| Nick DeLoach MIZZ | MAJ DEC 16-8 | Patrick Masterson |
| Andrew Scott NIU | PIN | Willie Wright Williams Baptist College |
| Jeremiah Moody IOWA | PIN | Matt Pratt Maryville University |
| Christian Kaser Missouri Valley College | PIN | Broc Smith Graceland University |
| Kyle Jolas Lindenwood University | PIN | Nick Hooper Williams Baptist College |
| Kyle Nixon Davenport University | TF 17-1 | Jake Mattson Missouri Baptist University |
