| Round of 32 |
| Jacob Brock Missouri Valley College | DEC 11-5 | Erik Cooley Williams Baptist College |
| Tanner Anthony McKendree University | DEC 9-4 | Noah Lester Graceland University |
| Logan Lundelius McKendree University | DEC 8-4 | Michael Chatman Lindenwood-Belleville |
| Henry Reyes Williams Baptist College | DEC 7-5 | Ike Podel LIB |
| Alex Butler MIZZ | DEC 7-2 | Tony Vaughn UINDY |
| Dustin Hayden Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College | DEC 7-5 | Will Steltzlen University of Central Oklahoma |
| Cole Wysocki PUR | TF 15-0 | Nicholas Greco Maryville University |
| Aaron Meyer IOWA | PIN | Austin Duren Missouri Valley College |
| Jason Box Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College | DEC 4-2 | Brandon Archuleta Bethany College |
| Jeren Glosser IOWA | PIN | Cole Franklin Neosho County Community College |
| Nate Limmex PUR | TF 17-1 | Tyler Jones Wentworth Military Academy |
| Patrick Grigsby Williams Baptist College | DEC 16-15 | Max Fisher NIU |
| Michael Kemerer IOWA | PIN | Dylan Brazell Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| Matt Wempen IOWA | DEC 2-1 | Conner Loderhose Ouachita Baptist University |
| Eric Barone ILL | PIN | Alex `Asa` Nelson Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
