| Consi 16 #2 |
| Gino Fluri RIDER | DEC 5-2 | Lawrance Dudgeon Ashland University |
| Ryan Skonieczny University of Findlay | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Kenneth Reinhart MSU |
| Jayce Carr Cleveland State University | DEC 9-7 | Josh Wimer University of Findlay |
| Matt Gudenau MSU | TF 17-0 | Zachary Ruggles Lake Erie College |
| Ian Ross Lake Erie College | DEC 11-5 | Kyle Todrank PUR |
| Brad Green NIU | PIN | Lawrence Blackful III Tiffin University |
| Kyle Noonan CMU | MAJ DEC 16-6 | Avery Henry EDIN |
| Travis Salyer Tiffin University | DEC 5-3 | Tyler Field Lake Erie College |
| Gino Fluri RIDER | DEC 3-1 | Matt Gudenau MSU |
| Kyle Ayersman PUR | PIN | Luke Klein Grand Valley State |
| Kyle Noonan CMU | MAJ DEC 21-7 | Joey Montney Grand Valley State |
| Joshua Davis Lake Erie College | DEC 3-2 | Sa'Derian Perry EMU |
| Mousa Jodeh ILL | DEC 3-1 | Kyle Lukowich KENT |
| Kyle Ayersman PUR | TF 16-0 | Matthew Liggett CLAR |
| Sa'Derian Perry EMU | FORFEIT | Sam Recco EDIN |
| Jayce Carr Cleveland State University | DEC 10-5 | Brad Green NIU |
| Ian Ross Lake Erie College | DEFAULT | Ryan Skonieczny University of Findlay |
| Travis Salyer Tiffin University | FORFEIT | Cameron Kennedy MICH |
| Mousa Jodeh ILL | MAJ DEC 14-0 | Joel Rosko CLAR |
| Joel Rosko CLAR | TF 15-0 | Robert Montney Grand Valley State |
