| Round of 16 |
| Lance Moore SUNY-Cortland | PIN | Ammar Obeidet Long Island University |
| James Bethel Oneonta State | DEC 8-2 | Emanual Zamora Jamestown Community College |
| Jacob Aiken-Phillips COR | PIN | Daniel Glinko Ithaca College |
| Garrett Ryan COLU | DEC 12-5 | Sam Weinger Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Mike Hughes HOF | PIN | Wyatt Morris Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Patryk Kopczynski Hunter College | TF 19-2 | Jonathan Cirino SUNY Sullivan |
| Cole Tristram SUNY Brockport | DEC 4-2 | Nico Burgos Niagara County Community College |
| Adam Groesbeck Oneonta State | DEC 2-0 | Robert Incorvaia COR |
| Joseph Sprung Ithaca College | PIN | Juan Nunez Alfred State College |
| Jake Gunning BUFF | DEC 3-0 | Austin Buttry USMA Prep School |
| George Famutimi COR | DEC 2-1 | Anthony Osman Alfred State College |
| Marvin Jean Simon Nassau Community College | PIN | Ross Lapides Farmingdale State College |
| Mason Kumashiro ARMY | DEC 5-3 | Kenneth Davenport Ithaca College |
