| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Evan Wallace Oneonta State | PIN | Cory Goshkagarian HOF |
| Anthony Cimirossi Niagara County Community College | DEC 11-4 | Ralph Canzetta Nassau Community College |
| Nicholas Wilke Hunter College | DEC 5-2 | Curtis Rowley Oneonta State |
| Nicholas Petrie Oneonta State | PIN | Justin Martinez NYU |
| Tyler Zimmer COLU | PIN | Brian Conrad BING |
| Javier Rodriguez ARMY | TF 16-1 | Craemer Hedash ARMY |
| James Devine SUNY Brockport | FORFEIT | Michael Illicete Farmingdale State College |
| Bernard Mcmillan Niagara County Community College | DEFAULT | Stephen Leibler Unattached |
| Nikolas Hansen Ithaca College | PIN | Edwin Bliemeister SUNY-Cortland |
| Kevin Thayer Alfred State College | TF 19-2 | Timmothy Rathbun Alfred State College |