| Finals |
| Bryce Barnes ARMY1st | FORFEIT | Morgan McIntosh PSU2nd |
| Medal Round |
| David Reck VT3rd | 4-3 | Nick Mabry Unattached4th |
| Anthony Cassar Unattached5th | FORFEIT | — |
| Consi Semi |
| Frank Mattiace Unattached | 8-0 | Anthony Cassar Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Bryce Barnes ARMY | 5-2 | Frank Mattiace Unattached |
| Morgan McIntosh PSU | 13-2 | David Reck VT |
| Consi 4 |
| Steven Congerie Unattached | 14-10 | — |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Garrett Wesneski Unattached | 6-2 | Brandon Litten Unattached |
| Anthony Cassar Unattached | 6-1 | Dustin Conti Unattached |
| Steven Congerie Unattached | 11-6 | Caleb Wallace BING |
| Tristan Sponseller Unattached | 8-3 | Benjamin Honis Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Bryce Barnes ARMY | 5-2 | Dustin Conti Unattached |
| Frank Mattiace Unattached | PIN 2:46 | Garrett Wesneski Unattached |
| David Reck VT | 6-3 | Tristan Sponseller Unattached |
| Morgan McIntosh PSU | 9-1 | Steven Congerie Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Brandon Litten Unattached | 3-1 | Jake Anderson Unattached |
| Anthony Cassar Unattached | 10-4 | Alen Turcinhodzic Unattached |
| Caleb Wallace BING | 6-2 | Derrick Maisonet Unattached |
| Benjamin Honis Unattached | 10-7 | Jacob Hart Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Jake Anderson Unattached | 16-3 | Bryson Begley WVU |
| Alen Turcinhodzic Unattached | 9-0 | — |
| Anthony Cassar Unattached | PIN 1:03 | — |
| Jacob Hart Unattached | 3-2 | — |
| Round of 16 |
| Dustin Conti Unattached | 2-1 | Jacob Hart Unattached |
| Bryce Barnes ARMY | 15-6 | Benjamin Honis Unattached |
| Garrett Wesneski Unattached | PIN 2:05 | Josh Rogers PSU |
| Frank Mattiace Unattached | PIN 1:27 | Antonio Pelusi FM |
| David Reck VT | 5-1 | Anthony Cassar Unattached |
| Tristan Sponseller Unattached | 9-4 | Alen Turcinhodzic Unattached |
| Steven Congerie Unattached | 14-3 | Jake Anderson Unattached |
| Morgan McIntosh PSU | PIN 1:32 | Edgar Ruano Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Jacob Hart Unattached | 3-1 | Brandon Litten Unattached |
| Bryce Barnes ARMY | 17-2 | Bryson Begley WVU |
| Josh Rogers PSU | 5-0 | Nick Mabry Unattached |
| Frank Mattiace Unattached | 11-0 | Jake Temple Unattached |
| Anthony Cassar Unattached | 5-2 | Caleb Wallace BING |
| Alen Turcinhodzic Unattached | 6-5 | Derrick Maisonet Unattached |
| Steven Congerie Unattached | PIN | Connor Route Unattached |
| Morgan McIntosh PSU | PIN | Tom Murray Unattached |
