| Finals |
| Matt McCutcheon Unattached1st | 8-0 | Zack Zavatsky Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round |
| James Frascella PSU3rd | 4-3 | Paul Schoenberg Unattached4th |
| Jack McKeever BING5th | 4-3 | — |
| Consi Semi |
| Anthony Pafumi Unattached | 7-3 | James Frascella PSU |
| Semifinal |
| Zack Zavatsky Unattached | PIN | Anthony Pafumi Unattached |
| Matt McCutcheon Unattached | 5-2 | Jack McKeever BING |
| Consi 4 |
| Nathan Dow ARMY | 7-3 | — |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Zach Bruce Unattached | 9-7 | Samson Imonode ARMY |
| James Frascella PSU | PIN 2:15 | Matt Doggett COLU |
| Nicholas Weldon Unattached | PIN 4:53 | Ali Yildiz RIDER |
| Nathan Dow ARMY | FORFEIT | Anthony Messner Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Zack Zavatsky Unattached | 9-3 | James Frascella PSU |
| Anthony Pafumi Unattached | 7-3 | Samson Imonode ARMY |
| Jack McKeever BING | DQ | Anthony Messner Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Zach Bruce Unattached | 9-3 | Tyler McLees ARMY |
| Matt Doggett COLU | PIN 2:13 | Amro Elansari Unattached |
| Nicholas Weldon Unattached | 15-2 | Nicholas Shawley Unattached |
| Nathan Dow ARMY | MED. FORFEIT | Lucky Shaut Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Zach Bruce Unattached | 3-1 | — |
| Tyler McLees ARMY | 20-12 | Greg Thurston WVU |
| Amro Elansari Unattached | 11-4 | Nicholas Shawley Unattached |
| Nicholas Weldon Unattached | 9-4 | Nick Cortopassi Unattached |
| Nathan Dow ARMY | 15-3 | — |
| Round of 16 |
| James Frascella PSU | 11-3 | Scott Votino ARMY |
| Zack Zavatsky Unattached | 12-2 | Nathan Dow ARMY |
| Samson Imonode ARMY | 10-8 | Nicholas Weldon Unattached |
| Anthony Pafumi Unattached | 12-2 | Kurtis Hewitt Middlesex Community College |
| Jack McKeever BING | 15-0 | Dalton Shoop ARMY |
| Anthony Messner Unattached | 7-1 | Matt Doggett COLU |
| Ali Yildiz RIDER | 8-3 | Tyler McLees ARMY |
| Round of 32 |
| Scott Votino ARMY | 12-4 | Mark Tracy Unattached |
| Nathan Dow ARMY | 13-3 | Greg Thurston WVU |
| Nicholas Weldon Unattached | 9-4 | Paul Schoenberg Unattached |
| Anthony Pafumi Unattached | PIN 6:42 | Amro Elansari Unattached |
| Jack McKeever BING | 12-0 | Nicholas Shawley Unattached |
| Anthony Messner Unattached | 15-0 | Nick Cortopassi Unattached |
| Tyler McLees ARMY | 14-2 | Jeremy Benton Unattached |
| Zach Bruce Unattached | 6-1 | Lucky Shaut Unattached |
