| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Dennis Gustafson Unattached1st | 8-1 | Tyson Dippery Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Brock Zacherl Unattached3rd | 5-2 | — |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Brock Zacherl Unattached | 22-8 | Dan Markosky Unattached |
| Semifinal | ||
| Dennis Gustafson Unattached | 6-3 | Michael Waters PSU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Gerald Ronnau VT | 6-5 | Matthew Kelly ARMY |
| Brock Zacherl Unattached | 10-2 | Matt Bryer Unattached |
| Paul Kirchner RIDER | 7-5 | Will Koll Unattached |
| Cortlandt Schuyler Unattached | 9-5 | Jason Bing FM |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Matthew Kelly ARMY | 11-2 | Sam Butler FM |
| Brock Zacherl Unattached | PIN 4:33 | Kyle Jensen Middlesex Community College |
| Paul Kirchner RIDER | PIN 2:43 | — |
| Jason Bing FM | 7-0 | Jacob Trybus Unattached |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Kade Moss Unattached | 10-3 | Matt Bryer Unattached |
| Tyson Dippery Unattached | 11-3 | Gerald Ronnau VT |
| Dennis Gustafson Unattached | 9-7 | Cortlandt Schuyler Unattached |
| Michael Waters PSU | 8-0 | Will Koll Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Matthew Kelly ARMY | 12-5 | — |
| Kyle Jensen Middlesex Community College | PIN 6:43 | — |
| Jack Lucie ARMY | 4-3 | Jalen Ramos Unattached |
| Jason Bing FM | 10-1 | — |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Kade Moss Unattached | 9-4 | Jason Bing FM |
| Matt Bryer Unattached | 10-2 | Jacob Trybus Unattached |
| Gerald Ronnau VT | PIN 2:54 | Jack Lucie ARMY |
| Cortlandt Schuyler Unattached | PIN 2:45 | Brock Zacherl Unattached |
| Dennis Gustafson Unattached | PIN 3:25 | Kyle Jensen Middlesex Community College |
| Will Koll Unattached | 16-1 | Sam Butler FM |
| Michael Waters PSU | 12-5 | Matthew Kelly ARMY |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Jason Bing FM | 15-4 | Dan Markosky Unattached |
| Tyson Dippery Unattached | PIN | Jake Stanford Unattached |
| Jack Lucie ARMY | 8-0 | Kyle Greenwald Unattached |
| Brock Zacherl Unattached | 13-1 | Jalen Ramos Unattached |
| Dennis Gustafson Unattached | 14-4 | Paul Kirchner RIDER |
| Michael Waters PSU | 21-3 | Brandon Walker Unattached |