| Finals |
| Jordan Conaway PSU1st | 10-3 | Dalton Macri Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Penn Gottfried Unattached3rd | 3-0 | Josh Patrick Unattached4th |
| Consi Semi |
| Penn Gottfried Unattached | PIN 2:16 | — |
| Semifinal |
| Jordan Conaway PSU | 11-2 | Sean Russell Unattached |
| Dalton Macri Unattached | 3-1 | Darian Cruz Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Kenny Yanovich Unattached | 5-2 | Michael Beck Unattached |
| Josh Patrick Unattached | PIN 2:30 | George Carpenter Unattached |
| Brandon Olsen Unattached | 5-2 | Britain Carter COLU |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Kenny Yanovich Unattached | 11-1 | James Sulkosky Unattached |
| George Carpenter Unattached | 7-3 | Edgar Garcia FM |
| Brandon Olsen Unattached | 7-5 | Zach Valcarce RIDER |
| Quarterfinal |
| Sean Russell Unattached | 11-3 | Josh Patrick Unattached |
| Dalton Macri Unattached | 27-13 | Joe Nelson Unattached |
| Darian Cruz Unattached | 4-2 | Britain Carter COLU |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| James Sulkosky Unattached | 5-2 | Scott Stossel Unattached |
| Edgar Garcia FM | PIN 1:27 | Middlesex Community |
| Brandon Olsen Unattached | 3-1 | Anthony Rivera Unattached |
| Ryan Elliott WVU | PIN 2:30 | — |
| Round of 16 |
| Sean Russell Unattached | 18-8 | Penn Gottfried Unattached |
| Josh Patrick Unattached | 15-0 | Aaron Doll Unattached |
| Michael Beck Unattached | 6-5 | Zach Valcarce RIDER |
| Jordan Conaway PSU | 17-2 | Brandon Olsen Unattached |
| Dalton Macri Unattached | 24-9 | George Carpenter Unattached |
| Joe Nelson Unattached | 8-5 | Edgar Garcia FM |
| Darian Cruz Unattached | 9-1 | Kenny Yanovich Unattached |
| Britain Carter COLU | 8-4 | Scott Stossel Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Penn Gottfried Unattached | 9-4 | James Sulkosky Unattached |
| Zach Valcarce RIDER | 18-3 | Brandon Hyman Middlesex Community College |
| Dalton Macri Unattached | 14-6 | Anthony Rivera Unattached |
| Kenny Yanovich Unattached | 11-2 | Ryan Elliott WVU |
