| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi Pigtail | ||
| Jackson Stabile Kutztown University | DEC 6-0 | Dario Dobbin PITT-J |
| Mike Stepien LEH | PIN | Matt Herbert SHU |
| Thomas Quinlan FM | DEC 4-1 | Michael Pritchard MVILLE |
| Joe Bickelman Kutztown University | PIN | Alex Harnsberger SHU |
| Mitch Voelker Kutztown University | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Nicholas Maccini DREX |
| Darryl Albonico NYU | FORFEIT | Tanner Sutton LHU |
| Cameron Scalio Kutztown University | DEC 6-5 | Brian Nelson BLOOM |
| Drew Spector York College (Pa.) | PIN | John Buhagiar York College (Pa.) |
| Steven Galiardo BRWN | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Oliver Hilgartner Unattached |
| Sam Bulagay York College (Pa.) | DEC 6-5 | John Allenson York College (Pa.) |
| Shane Arechiga Unattached | DEC 10-4 | Lincoln Mallinger ARMY |