| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Mike Stepien LEH | DEC 9-6 | Jackson Stabile Kutztown University |
| Patrick Hogan Unattached | TF 15-0 | Thomas Quinlan FM |
| Joe Bickelman Kutztown University | PIN | Josh Durham OKLA |
| Mitch Voelker Kutztown University | FORFEIT | Darryl Albonico NYU |
| Drew Spector York College (Pa.) | PIN | Cameron Scalio Kutztown University |
| Steven Galiardo BRWN | DEC 9-6 | Dylan Caruana BING |
| Jonathan Clemente NAVY | PIN | Sam Bulagay York College (Pa.) |
| Justin Alexander Unattached | DEFAULT | Shane Arechiga Unattached |