| Round of 64 |
| Edward Ruth Nittany Lion Wrestling Club | TF 17-7 | Nolan Boyd OKST |
| Douglas Gelbach Panther Wrestling Club | PIN | R.j. Troye NIU |
| James Mannier Navy Mat Club | TF 11-0 | Dj Roberson |
| Anthony Abro EMU | DEC 9-6 | Robert Marchese Bison Legend Wrestling Clubh |
| Scott Patrick Unattached | DEC 5-3 | Chaz Gresham Bobcat Wrestling Club |
| Derek Thomas Wolverine Wrestling Club | PIN | Danny Balderas PMN Butta |
| Canaan Bethca WPAC | DEC 12-6 | Mark Colabucci Mountaineer WC |
| Max Thomusseit Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | PIN | Colin Farawell Bison Legend Wrestling Clubh |
| Victor Terrell Grand Canyon Wrestling Club | TF 11-0 | Clay Dent CWC |
| Nick Vetell AppStateRTC | TF 12-0 | Tony Gardner Terrapin Wrestling Club |
| Kris Klapprodt Hawkeye Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Jon Volp Minnesota Storm |
| Phillip Joseph EMU | TF 10-0 | John Shrader CWC |
| Alex Stanley Patriot Elite Wrestling Club | DEC 9-8 | Dylan Dailey Nittany Lion Wrestling Club |
| Nicholas Bayer Bear Cave | TF 10-0 | Sam Shirey Husky Wrestling Club |
| Patrick Martinez Unattached | DEC 14-7 | Ryan Hembury Patriot Elite Wrestling Club |
| Matt Miller Navy Mat Club | DEC 11-5 | Ryan Sheldon Kohawks |
| Victor Avery EDIN | DEC 4-0 | Thomas Kimbrell Unattached |
| Cam Simaz Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Caleb Busson NIU |
| Alex Meyer Hawkeye Wrestling Club | TF 14-3 | Matthew Lewellen Dragon Wrestling Club |
| P.J. Tasser Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | PIN | Wesley Phipps Nittany Lion Wrestling Club |
| Brett Pfarr Minnesota Storm | TF 18-8 | Austin Morehead NWRTC |
| Michael Dessino Husky Wrestling Club | PIN | Colin Hedash AppStateRTC |
| Gabe Dean Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | TF 11-0 | Brian Engdahl NWRTC |
| Kyle Crutchmer OKST | TF 10-0 | Ryan Ward Unattached |
