| Round of 64 |
| Kyle Ash GWU | DEC 16-9 | Eric Nutter Pittsburgh Wrestling Club |
| Tyler Nauman DREX | DEC 10-6 | Christian Barber UNC |
| Derek Golner UNC | DEFAULT | Kasey Davis EDIN |
| Mitchell Minotti Lehigh Valley Athletic Club | TF 13-3 | Connor Sutton NYAC-Harlem |
| Cole Sheptock Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 4-3 | Alex Griffin Midwest RTC |
| Tommy Gantt Wolfpack Wrestling Club | TF 11-0 | Matthew Huffstickler Patriot Elite Wrestling Club |
| Andrew Morse NIU | TF 11-0 | Christopher Talevi Unattached |
| George Ivanov Bronco Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Clay Welter Panther Wrestling Club |
| Brad Dolezal Minnesota Storm | DEC 10-2 | John Boyle DCAC |
| Tom Giaimo Minnesota Storm | DEC 9-5 | Tywan Claxton Bobcat Wrestling Club |
| Nick Tourville Boston University | TF 11-0 | Colin Shober NW |
| Shohei Takagi Patriot Elite Wrestling Club | PIN | T.j. Keklak Golden Pride Wrestling Club |
| Kevin Tao DCAC | TF 12-1 | Lucas Swalla ISU |
| Pat Smith Minnesota Storm | TF 10-0 | Trey Duncan Navy Mat Club |
| Joe Schumacher NWRTC | TF 13-2 | David Kellogg Viking Wrestling Club |
| Robert Shepherd PAWS RTC | TF 13-2 | Branden Parker Samurai |
| Zane Zeman Minnesota Storm | TF 11-0 | Jacob Rockoff Bobcat Wrestling Club |
| Justin DeAngelis OKLA | TF 10-0 | Caleb Livingston Nittany Lion Wrestling Club |
| Dylan Cottrell AppStateRTC | TF 11-0 | Jake Kadel Hawkeye Wrestling Club |
| Kevin Hartnett Husky Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Zachary Kechter AppStateRTC |
| Derek Geiges OKLA | DEC 14-6 | Nick Terdick Blue & Gold Wrestling Club |
| Jacob Kingett VBRTC | TF 12-2 | Robert Hughes Michigan Wrestling Club |
| Yoanse Mejias Florida Jets | TF 11-0 | Robert Henderson UNC |
| Brandon Arnsberge Bloomburg | DEFAULT | Joseph Locksmith Navy Mat Club |
| Nick Heilmann UNC | TF 10-0 | Jared Reece Team Tornado |
| Brandon Kingsley Minnesota Storm | DEC 10-5 | Tucker Ray Wolverine Wrestling Club |
| Will Keeter Minnesota Storm | DEC 9-4 | Brad Mutchnik DCAC |
| Alexander Richardson VBRTC | DEC 7-2 | Jared Presley CWC |
| Matthew Frisch Citadel Old Timers Club, Inc. | TF 17-7 | Matt Smith NIU |
| Chris Castillo Bronco Wrestling Club | PIN | Aaron Scott AppStateRTC |
| Domenic Pietropeolo Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | TF 14-4 | Dalton Mudgett MO Valley Wrestling |
| Michael Hooker CWC | DEC 18-17 | Raamiah Bethea WPAC |
