| Finals |
| Nick Gwiazdowski Unattached1st | 12-1 | Jimmy Lawson PSU2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Douglas Vollaro Unattached | 5-1 | Jake Kettler Unattached |
| Matt Tourdot ODU | 5-2 | Billy Smith RU |
| Semifinal |
| Nick Gwiazdowski Unattached | PIN 3:06 | Jon Gingrich PSU |
| Jimmy Lawson PSU | 2-1 | Odie Delaney CIT |
| Consi 4 |
| Jake Kettler Unattached | PIN 1:04 | Phillip Catrucco CLAR |
| Billy Smith RU | 4-2 | Ty Walz Unattached |
| Douglas Vollaro Unattached | 3-1 | Nick Tavanello Unattached |
| Matt Tourdot ODU | 4-3 | Dan Garwood VT |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Nick Tavanello Unattached | 6-3 | Harry Turner LHU |
| Dan Garwood VT | 6-4 | Mike Kosoy NCST |
| Ty Walz Unattached | 4-1 | Zeal McGrew Unattached |
| Phillip Catrucco CLAR | 5-0 | Jedd Mason BUFF |
| Quarterfinal |
| Nick Gwiazdowski Unattached | 9-4 | Matt Tourdot ODU |
| Jimmy Lawson PSU | PIN 6:18 | Jake Kettler Unattached |
| Odie Delaney CIT | 5-3 | Douglas Vollaro Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Jedd Mason BUFF | PIN 2:14 | Lucas Ryan Unattached |
| Dan Garwood VT | 6-5 | Chris Penny Unattached |
| Harry Turner LHU | 4-1 | Jimmy Trull Unattached |
| Zeal McGrew Unattached | 3-2 | Terrance Jean-Jaques Unattached |
| Nick Tavanello Unattached | PIN 0:43 | Gerald Johnson CIT |
| Ty Walz Unattached | 10-5 | Kevin Innis Boston University |
| Phillip Catrucco CLAR | 10-6 | Chris Nash MSU |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Nick Tavanello Unattached | PIN 2:16 | Wyatt Baker COLU |
| Mike Kosoy NCST | 6-2 | Curtis Garner ARMY |
| Ty Walz Unattached | PIN 5:34 | Amro Elansari Unattached |
| Phillip Catrucco CLAR | 6-2 | Cody Mason LHU |
| Jimmy Trull Unattached | 4-0 | Brendan Kahle NAVY |
| Jedd Mason BUFF | 15-7 | Carl Buchholz MD |
| Dan Garwood VT | PIN 2:44 | Justin Heiserman BUFF |
| Zeal McGrew Unattached | MED. FORFEIT | Joe Nolan CAMP |
| Round of 16 |
| Jake Kettler Unattached | 10-9 | Kevin Innis Boston University |
| Billy Smith RU | PIN 5:51 | Lucas Ryan Unattached |
| Odie Delaney CIT | 8-1 | Danny Davis ODU |
| Matt Tourdot ODU | 3-1 | Harry Turner LHU |
| Douglas Vollaro Unattached | 8-4 | Chris Penny Unattached |
| Jon Gingrich PSU | 8-2 | Chris Nash MSU |
| Jimmy Lawson PSU | 6-0 | Terrance Jean-Jaques Unattached |
| Nick Gwiazdowski Unattached | PIN 2:39 | Gerald Johnson CIT |
| Round of 32 |
| Billy Smith RU | 9-2 | Mike Kosoy NCST |
| Gerald Johnson CIT | PIN 3:29 | Joe Nolan CAMP |
| Jake Kettler Unattached | 3-1 | Brendan Kahle NAVY |
| Douglas Vollaro Unattached | 6-2 | Cody Mason LHU |
| Nick Gwiazdowski Unattached | PIN 2:33 | Zeal McGrew Unattached |
| Harry Turner LHU | PIN 2:59 | Amro Elansari Unattached |
| Odie Delaney CIT | 8-1 | Carl Buchholz MD |
| Jon Gingrich PSU | 6-2 | Dan Garwood VT |
| Terrance Jean-Jaques Unattached | 4-2 | Nick Tavanello Unattached |
| Chris Penny |
| Round of 64 |
| Terrance Jean-Jaques Unattached | 8-0 | Joseph Gaynor ARMY |
| Carl Buchholz MD | 5-0 | Lex Knapp Unattached |
| Wyatt Baker COLU | 6-0 | Jake Barnhart UNC |
| Zeal McGrew Unattached | 5-1 | Dawson Peck Unattached |
| Ty Walz Unattached | 10-5 | Frank Schaafsma MD |
| Mike Kosoy NCST | 4-0 | Amon Willis Cleveland State University |
| Amro Elansari Unattached | PIN 1:27 | Brock Langley Army Prep |
| Cody Mason LHU | PIN 3:24 | Mimmo Lytle Unattached |
| Phillip Catrucco CLAR | 11-2 | Raymon Stone Unattached |
