| 6-3 |
| Tyler Rauenzahn ARMY |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | PIN 1:11 | Derek Goodwin Unattached |
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | PIN 4:32 | Blake Morder CLAR |
| Tyler Hunt Unattached | 3-1 | Cody Ross Unattached |
| Will Switzer Unattached | PIN 2:55 | Ryan Howes BUFF |
| Brent Jorge Unattached | 7-5 | John Matacic CLAR |
| Samuel Sherlock CLAR | 9-3 | Kyle Moran PSU |
| PIN 4:31 |
| Danny O'Malley MD |
| Tyler Hunt Unattached | 7-6 | Sam Hanau CMU |
| Cody Ross Unattached | PIN 5:21 | Donald Minnier Unattached |
| Jamel Hudson Unattached | 17-5 | Jason Stephen Unattached |
| Tyler Scotton Boston University | 11-7 | Mike Avelar NCST |
| Ben Matthiesen CMU | 6-0 | Justin Van Hoose Virginia |
| Zack Beitz Unattached | 12-4 | Joseph Gosinski Unattached |
| Kyle Moran PSU | 9-0 | Bradley Molina MD |
| R.J. LaBeef Cleveland State University | 11-2 | Tim Bailey Unattached |
| Will Switzer Unattached | 11-3 | Gabe Gardner CAMP |
| Brent Jorge Unattached | 8-3 | David Batkowski Unattached |
| Ryan Howes BUFF | 6-0 | Matt Crockett AU |
| Blake Morder CLAR | PIN 1:12 | Aaron Harrigan Army Prep |
| Tyler Rauenzahn ARMY | 9-6 | Rj DeGeorge Unattached |
| Shyheim Brown Unattached | 12-0 | Ryan Hunsberger Unattached |
| Daniel Neff LHU | 13-1 | Eli Bienstock Unattached |
| Alex Johnson NAVY | 6-1 | Alec Mooradian Unattached |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | PIN 5:35 | Dan King Cleveland State University |
| Derek Goodwin Unattached | 5-0 | Wade Jacobson Unattached |
| Chris Mecate ODU | PIN 4:31 | Collin Harrell Unattached |