| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Morgan McIntosh Unattached | 11-2 | Josh Fox Unattached |
| Angelo Malvestuto BUFF | 3-1 | Max Wessell LEH |
| Marshall Haas CIT | 7-1 | Cameron King UVA |
| John Merickel CAMP | 5-2 | Zach Ward BUFF |
| Jacob Henderson ODU | 8-3 | Kevin Marvel NAVY |
| Matt Meadows Unattached | 11-3 | Mike Love NAVY |
| Billy George Unattached | 8-3 | Robert Doyle ARMY |
| Christian Boley MD | PIN 6:24 | Darren Hankins VT |
| KaRonne Jones Unattached | PIN 1:04 | Robert Borkowski Unattached |
| Bobby Lavelle VT | 20-6 | Jasper Ocker Unattached |
| Mike Mirra Unattached | DEFAULT | Antonio Giorgio UNC |
| Quentin Wright PSU | PIN 2:00 | Matthew Snook MD |
| Justin Ortega CLAR | 9-1 | Lukas Schaeffer NAVY |
| Kevin Beazley Unattached | 8-2 | Phil Sprenkle LHU |
| Josh Lackey NCST | PIN 5:49 | Jeremy Benton Unattached |
| Paul Rands Unattached | PIN 0:47 | Kenneth Smith LHU |