| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Brian Bokoski UNC | PIN 2:02 | Max Soria BUFF |
| John Pellegrino Unattached | 8-2 | Buddy Scarborough ODU |
| Robert Deutsch ODU | 6-1 | William Mason Unattached |
| David White Unattached | PIN 2:53 | Jericho Urmenita NAVY |
| Kaleb LeMaire Unattached | 16-3 | Jake Reinemund UNC |
| Nico Megaludis PSU | PIN 3:18 | Jordan Wigger Unattached |
| Nick Roberts Unattached | 9-4 | Paul O'Neill MD |
| Joseph Langel III RU | 10-4 | Alfredo Gray KENT |
| Steven Cox CIT | PIN 3:34 | Brad Farley Unattached |
| Anthony Zanetta Unattached | 17-0 | Ronald Hicks CLAR |
| Nathan Santhanam ARMY | 6-3 | Cade Mansfield Unattached |
| Eric Montoya CAMP | 13-2 | Johnson Mai Unattached |
| Nick Herrmann UVA | 5-1 | Sean McCabe Unattached |
| Nathan Kraisser UNC | 11-1 | Josh Polacek MD |
| Godwin Nyama PITT | 10-2 | Mike Soria BUFF |
| Bobby Rehm LHU | 18-2 | Vincent Moita BRWN |