| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals |
| Bobby Barnhisel NAVY1st | DEC 8-3 | Matt Donohoe Cleveland State University2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Aaron Sulzer EMU3rd | FORFEIT | Ryan Watts MSU4th |
| Conor Young Campbellsville (Ky.)5th | DEC 8-2 | Dustin Schultz PUR6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Dustin Schultz PUR | FORFEIT | Robert Burg NAVY |
| Conor Young Campbellsville (Ky.) | DEFAULT | Zach Vargo Lake Erie College |
| Semifinal | ||
| Bobby Barnhisel NAVY | DEC 4-2 | Aaron Sulzer EMU |
| Matt Donohoe Cleveland State University | FORFEIT | Ryan Watts MSU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Conor Young Campbellsville (Ky.) | DEC 5-1 | James Bennett Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Dustin Schultz PUR | DEFAULT | Jeffery Pelton Notre Dame College |
| Zach Vargo Lake Erie College | MAJ DEC 15-6 | Tommy Fehring Mount St. Joseph |
| Robert Burg NAVY | DEC 8-2 | Michael Carpenter MICH |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Conor Young Campbellsville (Ky.) | PIN | Malcolm Martin CMU |
| Dustin Schultz PUR | DEC 13-12 | Matt Smith NIU |
| Tommy Fehring Mount St. Joseph | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Dylan Arthur Unattached |
| Robert Burg NAVY | PIN | Mike Monson Cleveland State University |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ryan Watts MSU | PIN | Zach Vargo Lake Erie College |
| Aaron Sulzer EMU | DEC 3-1 | Jeffery Pelton Notre Dame College |
| Matt Donohoe Cleveland State University | DEC 10-9 | James Bennett Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Bobby Barnhisel NAVY | TF 17-1 | Michael Carpenter MICH |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Mike Monson Cleveland State University | DEC 3-2 | Josh Smith NIU |
| Malcolm Martin CMU | FORFEIT | Chase Snider Iowa Western Community College |
| Dylan Arthur Unattached | FORFEIT | Tommy Churchard PUR |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Zach Vargo Lake Erie College | PIN | Malcolm Martin CMU |
| Michael Carpenter MICH | DEC 9-5 | Dustin Schultz PUR |
| Matt Donohoe Cleveland State University | DEFAULT | Tommy Churchard PUR |
| Ryan Watts MSU | DEC 8-7 | Conor Young Campbellsville (Ky.) |
| James Bennett Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 6-0 | Tommy Fehring Mount St. Joseph |
| Jeffery Pelton Notre Dame College | DEC 6-3 | Robert Burg NAVY |
| Aaron Sulzer EMU | TF 17-2 | Josh Smith NIU |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Josh Smith NIU | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Dylan Arthur Unattached |
| Dustin Schultz PUR | FORFEIT | Chase Snider Iowa Western Community College |
| Tommy Churchard PUR | TF 20-4 | Mike Monson Cleveland State University |
| Conor Young Campbellsville (Ky.) | TF 18-2 | Matt Smith NIU |