| Round of 32 |
| Nic Skonieczny University of Findlay | DEC 5-2 | Tyler Kuch Olivet College |
| Angelo Latora MICH | PIN | Daniel Contreras Notre Dame College |
| Caleb Huff Alma College | DEC 4-3 | Jacob Weissend Olivet College |
| Carter Augustyn Grand Valley State | DEC 3-2 | Daniel Palmerino SUNY Brockport |
| Matt Van Curen EMU | DEC 5-2 | Lewis Cuccharia SUNY Brockport |
| Curtiss Brownell Alma College | PIN | Nick Davis Notre Dame College |
| Joey White University of Findlay | MAJ DEC 20-6 | Corey Decker Olivet College |
| Shawn McGhee Campbellsville (Ky.) | PIN | Zachary Benedict Lake Erie College |
| Gabe Stepanovich Grand Valley State | PIN | Patrick Campbell OSU |
| Sidney Logan Indiana Institute of Technology | MAJ DEC 19-9 | Ruben Burrows Notre Dame College |
| Dalton Nicely University of Findlay | PIN | Sam Viengmany Tiffin University |
| Takil Agnew Lincoln College | DEC 2-0 | Nathan Ball Lake Erie College |
| Collin Poynter Indiana Institute of Technology | FORFEIT | Josh Brabon SUNY Brockport |
| Graham Lough Lincoln College | PIN | Zach Tiell Tiffin University |
| Steven Johnson University of Findlay | DEC 5-3 | Joe DelConte SUNY Brockport |
| Jonatan Rivera Notre Dame College | PIN | Aaron Barker Grand Valley State |
