| Round of 32 |
| Chas Busz Cleveland State University | DEC 5-4 | Gabe Bartok Rend Lake College |
| Darius Henderson Lincoln College | TF 15-0 | Cameron Maldonado Unattached |
| Terry Turner MSU | PIN | Darrell Pampkin Rend Lake College |
| Michael Screptock Tiffin University | DEC 7-3 | Eddie Sanders Mount St. Joseph |
| Michael Labry Ashland University | DEC 6-2 | James Jenkins Notre Dame College |
| Michael Leonard SUNY Brockport | TF 19-2 | Bobby Montney Grand Valley State |
| Matt Darling Olivet College | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Joey Montney Grand Valley State |
| Brodie Scherer Notre Dame College | DEC 6-2 | Robert Mason Ashland University |
| Christian Olanowski MSU | DEC 9-4 | Casey Jones SUNY Brockport |
| Dakota Carie MSU | PIN | JJ McCaffrey Cleveland State University |
| Austin Gillihan Lake Erie College | TF 17-0 | Tyler Dempsey Grand Valley State |
| Ty Davis CMU | DEC 6-0 | Anthony Ayres Notre Dame College |
| Kourtney Odom Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 6-3 | Zach Case Alma College |
| Nicholas Baker Olivet College | TF 20-5 | Josh Hunter Ashland University |
| Alex Jones Lincoln College | DEC 5-3 | Vinny Punzone Notre Dame College |
| Nolan Dilts Ashland University | PIN | Tyler McCoy Tiffin University |
