| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Nathan Ball Lake Erie College | DEC 7-4 | Curtiss Brownell Alma College |
| Nic Skonieczny University of Findlay | DEC 8-4 | Corey Decker Olivet College |
| Jacob Weissend Olivet College | PIN | Sidney Logan Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Aaron Barker Grand Valley State | FORFEIT | Graham Lough Lincoln College |
| Daniel Palmerino SUNY Brockport | DEC 6-3 | Steven Johnson University of Findlay |
| Dalton Nicely University of Findlay | DEC 5-1 | Joe DelConte SUNY Brockport |
| Lewis Cuccharia SUNY Brockport | DEC 7-3 | Collin Poynter Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Patrick Campbell OSU | DEC 10-4 | Caleb Huff Alma College |