| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Bobby Rehm LHU | PIN 1:26 | Nahshon Garrett Unattached |
| Paul O'Neill Unattached | 6-1 | Logan Shanks CMU |
| Max Soria BUFF | 8-3 | Sean Boylan Unattached |
| Desmond Moore Kutztown University | 5-3 | Jake Corrill Unattached |
| Austin Miller BUCK | 10-5 | Richard Alarcon CIT |
| Coltin Fought NCST | 17-0 | Liberato Kyle Unattached |
| David Terao Unattached | 7-2 | Mike Sardo BING |
| Jordan Conaway Unattached | 12-6 | Derrick Nelson Unattached |
| Mark Maestrey RIDER | PIN 1:04 | John Trumbetti LHU |
| Erik Spjut VT | PIN 4:42 | Nick Lamoreaux Kutztown University |
| David White ARMY | 14-3 | Tyler Mullarkey Unattached |
| Nathan Santhanam ARMY | 7-3 | Bijan Banks Unattached |
| Chace Small Unattached | PIN 5:28 | Tyree Gardner Kutztown University |
| Conor Youtsey Army Prep | PIN 2:15 | Andrew Brown Cleveland State University |
| Jarrod Garnett Unattached | 10-3 | Sean Walton BUFF |