| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Sean Boylan Unattached | 4-0 | Tyree Gardner Kutztown University |
| Nahshon Garrett Unattached | 11-7 | Richard Alarcon CIT |
| Logan Shanks CMU | PIN 1:21 | John Trumbetti LHU |
| Derrick Nelson Unattached | 13-6 | Jake Corrill Unattached |
| Sean Walton BUFF | PIN 0:53 | Tyler Mullarkey Unattached |
| Liberato Kyle Unattached | DEFAULT | Mike Sardo BING |
| Nick Lamoreaux Kutztown University | 11-7 | Bijan Banks Unattached |
| Ryan Dowd Boston University | PIN | Andrew Brown Cleveland State University |