| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Wayne Black Mount St. Joseph | PIN | Michael Leonard SUNY Brockport |
| Brandon Treharne Tiffin University | DEC 4-0 | Joey White University of Findlay |
| Chris Teague Campbellsville (Ky.) | DEC 9-5 | Maurice Miller Notre Dame College |
| Andrew Ermatinger MSU | DEC 7-5 | Joe Johnson MSU |
| Sam Hanau CMU | DEC 4-2 | Ty Davis CMU |
| Jarrod Boone OSU | DEC 6-4 | Taylor Bolin Lindenwood University |
| Joe Randazzo IND | DEC 4-2 | Eric Wolfe Notre Dame College |
| Chris Kerwin IND | DEC 7-5 | Seth Taylor Lindsey Wilson College |