| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Steven Monk NDSU | PIN 3:10 | Corey Mock UNC |
| Shawn Perry WIS | DEC 5-2 | Casey Fuller EDIN |
| Ryan Zumwalt North Idaho College | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Christopher Santana California Baptist University |
| T.J. Hepburn University of Nebraska at Kearney | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Dakota Friesth WYO |
| Walter Peppelman HARV | — | Dominic Prezzia WVU |
| Napoleon Aniciete UVU | DEC 11-8 | Charlie McMartin UNCO |
| Tyler Banks HOF | PIN 4:13 | David Rios Menlo (Calif.) |
| Mallie Shuster KENT | DEC 8-2 | Josh Demas OSU |
| RJ Pena ORST | DEC 6-1 | George Ivanov BSU |
| Donnie Tasser PITT | DEC 6-2 | James Rafferty ARMY |
| Anthony Box CSUB | MAJ DEC 13-1 | Vicente Aboytes San Francisco State University |
| Brandon Zeerip MICH | PIN 5:00 | Elijah Jackson POLY |
| James Green NEB | PIN 5:25 | Kenny Staub BRWN |
| Austin Sommer DREX | PIN 6:09 | Ryan Konz IND |
| Kyle Dake COR | PIN 1:52 | Ross Taylor Western Wyoming College |
| Josh Kreimier AF | DEC 4-2 | Victor DeJesus ASU |