| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Craig Barker Unattached | 11-9 | Ian Abplanalp Mercyhurst University |
| Pat McCaffrey NAVY | PIN 1:51 | T.J. Mitchell Unattached |
| Drew Hammer Unattached | 2-0 | Eli Ashby CIT |
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | PIN 1:11 | Kristopher Lowery King University |
| Tyler Keselring Unattached | PIN 0:32 | Simon Wong Unattached |
| Jeremiah Biddle BLOOM | 7-4 | Ben Levin NAVY |
| Erik Galloway Unattached | 1-0 | Mason Goretsas Unattached |
| Victor Lipari Unattached | 6-2 | Zach Ellis PENN |
| Dan Riggi BING | 8-3 | Chad Deno Unattached |
| Caleb Myers King University | 17-2 | Elliot Zackoski Unattached |