| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Andrew Alton PSU | PIN 1:05 | Ben Matthiesen Unattached |
| Mike Tully PITT | 1-0 | Brian Guilfoyle BING |
| Dan Manley Unattached | 4-1 | Matthew Hasbrouck Unattached |
| Trevor Melde RU | 8-0 | Seth Beitz Unattached |
| Zach Neibert VT | 6-3 | Jordan Beverly RU |
| Mike Doria HOF | 15-8 | Jonathan Pearce King University |
| Seth Schaner EMU | PIN 3:55 | Kyle Paradiso Unattached |
| Danny Lopes UNC | 3-1 | Albert Woody LEH |
| Garet Pisani Unattached | 8-5 | Kyle Moran Unattached |
| Danny O'Malley MD | PIN 1:52 | Dillon Farrell Unattached |
| Andrew Schutt BUFF | PIN 0:26 | Bradley Molina Unattached |
| Mark Hartenstine Unattached | 8-4 | Tyler Bedelyon Unattached |
| Raymond Borja NAVY | PIN 4:36 | William Loftus Unattached |
| Adam Lynch PSU | 22-4 | Brandon Deamer Unattached |
| Zack Kemmerer PENN | 11-2 | Rocco Wellek UNC |
| Nick Murray VT | PIN 2:11 | Michael Savastano Unattached |