| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Craig Barker Unattached | 4-2 | Alex Schulmann Unattached |
| Mitchell Port Unattached | 6-1 | Erik Galloway Unattached |
| Shelton Mack PITT | 20-7 | Ryan Toussaint BLOOM |
| Matt Malfaro Unattached | 16-3 | Sean Diemma Unattached |
| Kevin Smith BUFF | 2-1 | Pat McCaffrey NAVY |
| Jeremiah Biddle BLOOM | 7-2 | Derrik Russell Unattached |
| Tyler Sackett NAVY | PIN 2:15 | Bryan Pearsall PSU |
| AJ Schopp Unattached | 17-1 | Tyler Keselring Unattached |
| Nicholas Meinsen Unattached | PIN 1:20 | Drew Hammer Unattached |
| Brock LiVorio Unattached | 16-1 | Daniel Calzarette Unattached |
| Matt Bystol COLU | 8-2 | Caleb Myers King University |
| Samuel Sherlock Unattached | 15-4 | Dan Riggi BING |
| Tyler Sim CIT | 23-7 | Jason Turpyn Unattached |
| Lou Ruland MD | 12-4 | Geoffrey Bostany PENN |
| Erik Spjut Unattached | 13-4 | Richard Alarcon CIT |
| Rob Vollrath Unattached | PIN 5:41 | Victor Lipari Unattached |