| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Kevin Nash MSU | 4-2 | Justin Haug Unattached |
| Christopher Smith BLOOM | 6-2 | Neal Williams Unattached |
| Sam Shirey BLOOM | PIN 1:24 | Frank Rainey Unattached |
| Jerry Rice EMU | 8-7 | Sven Alm Unattached |
| Alex Ortman EMU | 5-3 | Kenneth Radford CIT |
| Jared Sernoffsky Unattached | 4-0 | Trevor Wentt King University |
| Kyle Flick PITT | 4-2 | Jay Wieller Unattached |
| Ron Majerus BUFF | 7-0 | Dustin Tancredi Unattached |