| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| DJ Meagher Unattached | PIN 0:35 | Ryan Doyle COLU |
| Anthony Priore SHU | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Dylan Caprio Unattached |
| Jake O'Hara COLU | DEC 8-4 | Chad Lowman ODU |
| Zach Clemente Unattached | DEC 6-2 | Mark Cirello Unattached |
| Kevin Hartnett Unattached | DEC 5-4 | Nick Terdick Unattached |
| Brian Tanen LEH | DEC 2-1 | Derek Schreiner Unattached |
| Tyler Sheridan COLU | DEC 12-7 | Paul Hancock ARMY |
| Kris Shirley SUNY Brockport | PIN 6:16 | Paul Saviva Middlesex Community College |
| Walter Peppelman HARV | PIN 1:14 | Adam Fondale COLU |
| Tyler Banks Unattached | PIN 1:32 | Michael Roberson NYU |
| Craig Eifert Unattached | DEC 4-1 | Anson Worrell DREX |
| Daniel Kolodzik PRIN | DEC 6-2 | Gabe Brotzman Unattached |
| Ramon Santiago RIDER | DEC 4-1 | Aaron Fry Unattached |
| Bryce Busler Unattached | PIN 1:15 | Cody Bye ARMY |
| Jesse Shanaman COR | DEC 5-1 | Kevin Brown COLU |
| Tom Straughn Notre Dame College | DEC 11-4 | Micah Blair Unattached |