| Round of 32 |
| Corey Peltier Terrapin Wrestling Club | PIN | Hunter Collins Montoya Michigan Wrestling Club |
| Jimmy Hamel Buffalo Wrestling Club | DEC 1-0 | Peter Capone Ohio Regional Training Center |
| Ethan Headlee Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 2-0 | Nathan Graham Husky Wrestling Club |
| Kurt Brenner Unattached | DEC 3-1 | Kelan Bragg Cal Poly Wrestling Club |
| Ryan Loder UNI | DEC 7-1 | Rob Waltko Bison Wrestling Club |
| Austin Trotman Mountaineer Wrestling Club | DEC 2-0 | Ben Bridell OKLA |
| Brian Roddy NW | DEC 4-2 | Nick Tenpenny Carolina Wrestling Club |
| Ray Hell NIXA | PIN | Brent Eidenschink MN Storm |
| Jordan Blanton Illini Wrestling Club | DEC 4-1 | Todd Porter Rage Cage |
| Quentin Wright Nittany Lion Wrestling Club | DEC 6-0 | Grant Gambrall HWC |
| Ryan Garringer Bobcat Wrestling Club | DEC 3-2 | Bryant Blanton Bip! |
| Kadeem Samuels LVAC | TF 6-0 | Michael Lorenzo Nittany Lion Wrestling Club |
| Keena Washington Rick Sanders Wrestling | DEC 2-0 | Harrison Cook Sunkist Kids Wrestling Club |
| Nick Heflin Ohio Regional Training Center | DEC 4-0 | Colin McDonald COR |
| Doug Umbehauer Unattached | DEC 2-1 | Jonathan Fausey Cavalier Wrestling Club |
| Edward Ruth Nittany Lion Wrestling Club | DEC 3-3 | Deigo Bencomo DUKE |
