| Cons. Round 5 |
| Phil Sorrentino Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 3-1 | Kevin Hardy Unattached |
| Daniel Yates Michigan Wrestling Club | TF 6-0 | Pete Yates NRV Mat club |
| Corey Bleaken Cumberland University | PIN | Nick Fischer Nittany Lion Wrestling Club |
| Jacob Schalles Navy Mat Club | DEC 2-1 | Nik Turner OCU COBRA STARS |
| Tyler Koehn Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 2-2 | David Foxen Brown Bears WC |
| David Bonin UNI | DEC 5-0 | Bryce Busler Husky Wrestling Club |
| Brandon Wright chattanooga wrestling club | DEC 5-0 | Adam Zeh Whitewater Wrestling Club |
| Adam Counterman Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | DEC 1-1 | Tyler Sheridan Columbia Lions |
