| Finals |
| Nicholas Marable MIZZ1st | 15-6 | Scott Winston Unattached2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Jimmy Sheptock Unattached | 8-5 | Matt Kaylor BING |
| Stephen Burak PENN | 3-1 | Kyle Bounds MSU |
| Semifinal |
| Nicholas Marable MIZZ | 6-1 | Dennis Galante LEH |
| Scott Winston Unattached | 9-3 | Dan Vallimont PSU |
| Consi 4 |
| Kyle Bounds MSU | DEFAULT | Jake Kemerer Unattached |
| Matt Kaylor BING | DEFAULT | Ben Boudro MSU |
| Jimmy Sheptock Unattached | PIN 6:36 | Karl Deciantis PITT |
| Stephen Burak PENN | 7-3 | Daniel Yates Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Stephen Burak PENN | 9-3 | Mason Bailey NAVY |
| Ben Boudro MSU | 8-3 | Mike Dessino BLOOM |
| Karl Deciantis PITT | 3-2 | Thomas Timothy PENN |
| Kyle Bounds MSU | 3-2 | Robby Neill NAVY |
| Quarterfinal |
| Dan Vallimont PSU | 6-5 | Jimmy Sheptock Unattached |
| Nicholas Marable MIZZ | 5-2 | Daniel Yates Unattached |
| Dennis Galante LEH | 4-0 | Jake Kemerer Unattached |
| Scott Winston Unattached | 6-1 | Matt Kaylor BING |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Mason Bailey NAVY | 6-4 | Johnny Merryman Tiffin University |
| Karl Deciantis PITT | 12-8 | Kyle Czarnecki Boston University |
| Mike Dessino BLOOM | 9-2 | Andrik Cruz Unattached |
| Robby Neill NAVY | 3-2 | Julian Colon LIB |
| Ben Boudro MSU | 7-4 | C.J. Inglin Boston University |
| Kyle Bounds MSU | 10-3 | Matt Dodds PSU |
| Thomas Timothy PENN | PIN 1:55 | Kyle Keane PITT-J |
| Stephen Burak PENN | MED. FORFEIT | Derek Sickel CIT |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Julian Colon LIB | 15-5 | Clint Schaefer Mercyhurst University |
| Ben Boudro MSU | 11-2 | Joseph Bayer LIB |
| Mason Bailey NAVY | PIN 5:15 | Nick Kacznowski Unattached |
| Kyle Czarnecki Boston University | 5-1 | James Brundage Unattached |
| Stephen Burak PENN | PIN 2:30 | John Paris Unattached |
| Mike Dessino BLOOM | PIN 5:58 | Michael Brant NAVY |
| Kyle Bounds MSU | PIN 2:46 | Justin Sparrow CIT |
| Thomas Timothy PENN | PIN 1:04 | Kyle Bish Penn State DuBois |
| Round of 16 |
| Daniel Yates Unattached | 3-2 | Karl Deciantis PITT |
| Jimmy Sheptock Unattached | 14-5 | Johnny Merryman Tiffin University |
| Jake Kemerer Unattached | 3-2 | C.J. Inglin Boston University |
| Matt Kaylor BING | 3-1 | Robby Neill NAVY |
| Dennis Galante LEH | 9-5 | Andrik Cruz Unattached |
| Dan Vallimont PSU | DEFAULT | Derek Sickel CIT |
| Nicholas Marable MIZZ | 13-5 | Kyle Keane PITT-J |
| Scott Winston Unattached | 15-3 | Matt Dodds PSU |
| Round of 32 |
| Johnny Merryman Tiffin University | PIN 2:41 | Joseph Bayer LIB |
| C.J. Inglin Boston University | 8-5 | Nick Kacznowski Unattached |
| Dennis Galante LEH | 9-4 | Stephen Burak PENN |
| Dan Vallimont PSU | 18-6 | Mike Dessino BLOOM |
| Karl Deciantis PITT | PIN 1:38 | Clint Schaefer Mercyhurst University |
| Scott Winston Unattached | 11-6 | Thomas Timothy PENN |
| Andrik Cruz Unattached | 15-3 | John Paris Unattached |
| Robby Neill NAVY | 8-4 | James Brundage Unattached |
| Daniel Yates Unattached | 4-2 | Julian Colon LIB |
| Round of 64 |
| Ben Boudro MSU | PIN 4:02 | Camerom Price Unattached |
| Clint Schaefer Mercyhurst University | 4-2 | Jacob Schalles NAVY |
| Stephen Burak PENN | PIN 4:35 | Steven Ramos Unattached |
| Matt Dodds PSU | 8-7 | Josh Kassil Unattached |
| Karl Deciantis PITT | 8-1 | Chris Servian Unattached |
| Daniel Yates Unattached | PIN 2:06 | Mike Steltenkamp PENN |
| Derek Sickel CIT | PIN 3:46 | Kevin Ryan PITT-J |
| Kyle Czarnecki Boston University | 7-1 | Brett Shoenfelt Unattached |
| Justin Sparrow CIT | PIN 3:52 | Sam Shirey |
