| Finals |
| Cyler Sanderson PSU1st | 8-7 | David Taylor Unattached2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Eric Hess Unattached | 7-5 | Corey Lear Unattached |
| James Vollrath Unattached | PIN 1:31 | Mark Powell PITT |
| Semifinal |
| David Taylor Unattached | PIN 4:42 | Patrick Wright MIZZ |
| Cyler Sanderson PSU | 4-3 | Daryl Cocozzo Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Corey Lear Unattached | 6-5 | Ryan McGarity BING |
| Eric Hess Unattached | 3-2 | Johnny Greisheimer Unattached |
| Mark Powell PITT | 1-0 | Nick Fischer PSU |
| James Vollrath Unattached | 6-4 | Eugene Riley UVA |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Eugene Riley UVA | 17-3 | Chad Miller Unattached |
| Corey Lear Unattached | PIN 4:53 | Daniel Clarke UVA |
| Johnny Greisheimer Unattached | 8-6 | Anthony Priore SHU |
| Mark Powell PITT | 4-2 | Turtogtokh Luvsandorj CIT |
| Quarterfinal |
| Cyler Sanderson PSU | PIN 2:42 | Eric Hess Unattached |
| Patrick Wright MIZZ | 5-1 | Nick Fischer PSU |
| Daryl Cocozzo Unattached | 15-2 | Ryan McGarity BING |
| David Taylor Unattached | 14-2 | James Vollrath Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Mark Powell PITT | 4-3 | Zach Basich NAVY |
| Daniel Clarke UVA | 7-3 | Keith Ryan PITT-J |
| Eugene Riley UVA | 10-0 | Ben Mandebraut Boston University |
| Corey Lear Unattached | PIN 2:12 | Taylor Knapp Unattached |
| Chad Miller Unattached | 6-5 | Giorgio Gregoris MIZZ |
| Johnny Greisheimer Unattached | 10-4 | Dj Zarfos Unattached |
| Turtogtokh Luvsandorj CIT | PIN 2:33 | Shawn Mazzarone Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Chad Miller Unattached | 8-2 | Shayne Stewart Unattached |
| Johnny Greisheimer Unattached | 11-3 | Jude Tropona LHU |
| Taylor Knapp Unattached | 7-5 | Aaron Keeton GMU |
| Ben Mandebraut Boston University | 14-6 | Ryan Taylor Penn State DuBois |
| Shawn Mazzarone Unattached | 4-0 | Zane Newton CIT |
| Keith Ryan PITT-J | PIN 1:45 | Nathan Reinhart DUQ |
| Zach Basich NAVY | 10-5 | Alex Martinez DUQ |
| Anthony Priore SHU | 5-3 | Eric Resch Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Ryan McGarity BING | PIN 6:41 | Turtogtokh Luvsandorj CIT |
| Cyler Sanderson PSU | 5-4 | Eugene Riley UVA |
| Nick Fischer PSU | 3-1 | Corey Lear Unattached |
| James Vollrath Unattached | 4-2 | Dj Zarfos Unattached |
| Eric Hess Unattached | 7-2 | Giorgio Gregoris MIZZ |
| David Taylor Unattached | PIN 3:40 | Myers Miller PITT-J |
| Daryl Cocozzo Unattached | 8-3 | Mark Powell PITT |
| Patrick Wright MIZZ | 3-1 | Daniel Clarke UVA |
| Round of 32 |
| Turtogtokh Luvsandorj CIT | 17-8 | Johnny Greisheimer Unattached |
| Myers Miller PITT-J | 4-3 | Alex Martinez DUQ |
| Eric Hess Unattached | PIN 1:40 | Nathan Reinhart DUQ |
| Daryl Cocozzo Unattached | 11-1 | Anthony Priore SHU |
| Cyler Sanderson PSU | PIN 1:32 | Taylor Knapp Unattached |
| Patrick Wright MIZZ | PIN 1:05 | Shayne Stewart Unattached |
| Giorgio Gregoris MIZZ | 11-2 | Keith Ryan PITT-J |
| Eugene Riley UVA | 10-1 | Aaron Keeton GMU |
| Nick Fischer PSU | PIN 1:06 | Ben Mandebraut Boston University |
| Round of 64 |
| Ryan McGarity BING | 4-0 | Nick Vallone Unattached |
| Aaron Keeton GMU | 11-0 | Zack Strickland Unattached |
| Zach Basich NAVY | 10-4 | Josh Veltre BLOOM |
| Nathan Reinhart DUQ | 6-5 | Charles Aungst Unattached |
| Keith Ryan PITT-J | PIN 2:27 | Scott Sechler Unattached |
| Alex Martinez DUQ | 6-2 | Anthony Laverghetta LHU |
| Anthony Priore SHU | 10-3 | Greg Hilbert Unattached |
| Mark Powell PITT | 7-0 | Joe Benedetti Unattached |
| Johnny Greisheimer Unattached | 9-7 | Kyle O'Neill NAVY |
|
