| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Eric Filipowicz NAVY | 3-2 | Michael Fenton CIT |
| Collin Dozier MSU | PIN 5:38 | Colin Shober Unattached |
| Alex Cournoyer Boston University | 9-2 | Matt Bradley RIDER |
| Nick Nelson Unattached | 11-4 | Dan Osterman MSU |
| Michael Crowley Unattached | 9-2 | Seth Beitz Unattached |
| Todd Schavrien MIZZ | PIN 5:48 | Mike Nevinger Hicks Scrappin |
| Andrew Alton Unattached | PIN 4:53 | Albert Rush Boston University |
| Colby Pisani PSU | 6-4 | Aj Milanak Unattached |
| Dustin Haislip NAVY | 6-2 | Anthony Jerome BING |
| Dave Cawley Unattached | 11-2 | Kyle Begg Tiffin University |
| Adam Lynch PSU | 13-3 | Donald Takagi GMU |
| Nick Murray VT | 15-0 | Ronald Butler Cleveland State University |
| Tyler Nauman PITT | 12-0 | Nicholas Hucke MIZZ |
| Zack Kemmerer PENN | PIN 2:44 | Ian Squires Unattached |
| Cody Farinella MIZZ | PIN 2:40 | Brandon Rader Unattached |
| Anwar Goeres BING | PIN 1:14 | Josh Harper Unattached |