| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Christian Martino Unattached | 7-2 | Richy Reinoehl Unattached |
| Pat Strizki MD | 9-0 | Dan Riggi BING |
| Silas Murray Nassau Community College | 4-0 | Douglas Maiorano PITT-J |
| Brad Pataky PSU | 12-3 | Ryan Link PITT-J |
| Brad Wisdom MIZZ | 17-2 | Giazzi Segarra CIT |
| David Fogle Unattached | 9-7 | Kellen Aura LEH |
| Mark Rappo PENN | PIN 4:34 | Gabriel Gomez Unattached |
| Mike Rhone Unattached | 7-1 | Eric Caschera PSU |
| Anthony Zanetta PITT | 6-2 | Eric Olanowski MSU |
| Matthew Snyder Unattached | 7-6 | Rocardo Gomez Nassau Community College |
| Allan Stein NAVY | 13-4 | Coltin Fought Unattached |
| Jarrod Garnett VT | PIN 1:59 | Brenan Lyon Unattached |
| Zack Beitz Unattached | 11-5 | Vincent Dellefave Unattached |
| Tyler Sim Unattached | 11-3 | Jeremiah Austin MSU |
| Ross Gitomer UVA | PIN 3:19 | Justin Rivera Unattached |
| Brian Wright GMU | PIN 3:44 | Ryan Dowd Boston University |