| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Shane Valko PITT-J | DEFAULT | Brian Benton GMU |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | 12-2 | Rob Vollrath Unattached |
| Frank Cimato Unattached | 8-4 | Michael Fennell Unattached |
| Erik Galloway Unattached | 5-1 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Garrett Morabito BING | 7-4 | Bryan Pearsall PSU |
| Nathan McCormick MIZZ | 9-3 | Tyler Saltsman PSU |
| Nathan Pennesi Unattached | 7-4 | Filiberto Colon RIDER |
| Joey Boone Unattached | 3-0 | Alec Fraser Unattached |