| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Tyler Sim Unattached | 6-1 | Mike Rhone Unattached |
| Jarrod Garnett VT | 11-2 | David Fogle Unattached |
| Brad Pataky PSU | PIN 3:10 | Christian Martino Unattached |
| Mark Rappo PENN | 6-4 | Pat Strizki MD |
| Matthew Snyder Unattached | 8-2 | Zack Beitz Unattached |
| Ross Gitomer UVA | 8-2 | Silas Murray Nassau Community College |
| Allan Stein NAVY | 7-6 | Anthony Zanetta PITT |