| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Corey Waite BING | 7-3 | Justin Allen LEH |
| Fred Hale Mercyhurst University | PIN 1:14 | Dylan Dodson Unattached |
| Steve Andrus Unattached | PIN 2:50 | David Speaker GMU |
| Josh Krupa Unattached | 13-3 | Conor Sweeney Unattached |
| Mike Landis NAVY | 3-2 | Nathan Knepp BLOOM |
| John Rizqallah MSU | PIN 5:52 | Hunter Manspile GMU |
| Mike Cook Unattached | PIN 5:00 | Jim Mosher Penn State DuBois |
| Joe Breaux NAVY | 5-2 | Ivan Muller CIT |