| Finals |
| Brent Metcalf IOWA1st | DEC 9-2 | Kyle Ruschell WIS2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Kevin LeValley BUCK3rd | DEC 2-0 | Tony D'Alie CMU4th |
| Eric Albright PITT5th | FORFEIT | Mitch Mueller ISU6th |
| Kyle Borshoff AU7th | DEC 4-3 | David Cheza MSU8th |
| Consi Semi |
| Mitch Mueller ISU | DEC 3-1 | Kyle Borshoff AU |
| Kevin LeValley BUCK | DEC 9-5 | David Cheza MSU |
| Semifinal |
| Brent Metcalf IOWA | PIN 3:51 | Eric Albright PITT |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Tony D'Alie CMU |
| Consi 4 |
| Kyle Borshoff AU | DEC 7-3 | James Fleming CLAR |
| Mitch Mueller ISU | DEC 5-1 | RJ Pena ORST |
| David Cheza MSU | FORFEIT | Andrew Nadhir NW |
| Kevin LeValley BUCK | TF 17-0 | Shawn Perry Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| James Fleming CLAR | DEC 9-5 | Dan Ruettiger NIU |
| RJ Pena ORST | MAJ DEC 17-6 | Nick Bertucci PUR |
| Andrew Nadhir NW | DEC 3-2 | Mario Mason Unattached |
| Shawn Perry Unattached | DEC 7-3 | T.J. Hepburn University of Nebraska at Kearney |
| Quarterfinal |
| Brent Metcalf IOWA | MAJ DEC 12-3 | David Cheza MSU |
| Eric Albright PITT | DEC 9-6 | Kevin LeValley BUCK |
| Tony D'Alie CMU | DEC 5-3 | Kyle Borshoff AU |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | DEC 3-2 | Mitch Mueller ISU |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| James Fleming CLAR | DEC 2-0 | Greg Lewis CLAR |
| Dan Ruettiger NIU | PIN 2:49 | Jon Kohler MD |
| Nick Bertucci PUR | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Dean Pavlou CHAT |
| RJ Pena ORST | PIN 1:22 | Benny Garcia California Baptist University |
| Andrew Nadhir NW | DEC 16-9 | Brett Robbins UNI |
| Mario Mason Unattached | DEC 8-4 | Sam Patacsil PUR |
| T.J. Hepburn University of Nebraska at Kearney | DEC 2-0 | Justin Hale ISU |
| Shawn Perry Unattached | DEC 4-2 | Joey Napoli LEH |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| James Fleming CLAR | DEC 11-6 | Justin Morrill UVU |
| Jon Kohler MD | DEC 4-2 | Mike Kessler RIDER |
| Dean Pavlou CHAT | MAJ DEC 13-0 | Derrick Pousson Unattached |
| Benny Garcia California Baptist University | DEC 2-1 | Cody Farinella MIZZ |
| Brett Robbins UNI | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Nick Jones SIUE |
| Mario Mason Unattached | DEC 9-4 | Brian Stephens Unattached |
| Justin Hale ISU | DEC 6-3 | Jason Pyle Luther College |
| Shawn Perry Unattached | DEC 5-3 | Brandon Wiest MIZZ |
| Round of 16 |
| Brent Metcalf IOWA | PIN 1:36 | Nick Bertucci PUR |
| David Cheza MSU | PIN 7:21 | RJ Pena ORST |
| Eric Albright PITT | DEC 4-3 | Greg Lewis CLAR |
| Kevin LeValley BUCK | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Dan Ruettiger NIU |
| Kyle Borshoff AU | DEC 2-0 | T.J. Hepburn University of Nebraska at Kearney |
| Tony D'Alie CMU | DEC 7-5 | Joey Napoli LEH |
| Mitch Mueller ISU | DEC 7-2 | Andrew Nadhir NW |
| Kyle Ruschell WIS | DEC 9-3 | Sam Patacsil PUR |
| Consi 16 #1 |
| Justin Morrill UVU | DEC 4-1 | Donnie Vinson BING |
| Mike Kessler RIDER | DEC 8-3 | Jamal Lawrence UNI |
| Dean Pavlou CHAT | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Dan Castillo Cleveland State University |
| Cody Farinella MIZZ | PIN 4:19 | Alex Hudson CHAT |
| Nick Jones SIUE | FORFEIT | Paul Liguori HARV |
| Brian Stephens Unattached | MAJ DEC 15-6 | Justin McDermitt CMU |
| Shawn Perry Unattached | DEC 9-2 | Vince Hannon Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Brent Metcalf IOWA | PIN 3:32 | Brandon Wiest MIZZ |
| Nick Bertucci PUR | DEC 6-5 | Shawn Perry Unattached |
| David Cheza MSU | DEC 5-0 | Jason Pyle Luther College |
| RJ Pena ORST | DEC 7-3 | Justin Hale ISU |
| Greg Lewis CLAR | DEC 6-3 | Mario Mason Unattached |
| Eric Albright PITT | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Justin McDermitt CMU |
| Dan Ruettiger NIU | PIN 5:23 | Nick Jones SIUE |
| Kevin LeValley BUCK | PIN 2:53 | Brett Robbins UNI |
| Kyle Borshoff AU | DEC 4-1 | Benny Garcia California Baptist University |
| T.J. Hepburn |
| Round of 64 |
| Brent Metcalf IOWA | TF 22-6 | Justin Morrill UVU |
| David Cheza MSU | DEC 5-0 | Mike Kessler RIDER |
| Justin McDermitt CMU | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Dan Castillo Cleveland State University |
| Dan Ruettiger NIU | PIN 6:08 | Alex Hudson CHAT |
| T.J. Hepburn University of Nebraska at Kearney | DEFAULT | Paul Liguori HARV |
| Dean Pavlou CHAT | DEC 7-3 | Brian Stephens Unattached |
| James Fleming CLAR | DEC 3-0 | Vince Hannon Unattached |
