| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Anthony Lajara Unattached | PIN 1:53 | Oren Mayer Unattached |
| Tom Voorhis SUNY Brockport | PIN 2:40 | Chris Selvoski Stevens Institute of Technology |
| Cam Simaz Unattached | PIN 3:24 | Robert Prigmore LEH |
| Jeff Siciliano Delaware Valley University | PIN 1:58 | Boris Shulkia Yeshiva University |
| Larry Otsuka BRWN | DEC 3-1 | Sean Murphy HARV |
| Branden Stearns Unattached | DEC 7-3 | Matt Panasevich BRWN |
| Tyler Smith RIDER | DEC 9-2 | Brandon Shull BRWN |
| Micah Burak PENN | DEC 5-1 | Chris Manna COLU |
| Richard Perry | DEC 4-2 | Ernie Guaimano Stevens Institute of Technology |
| Charles Fox PRIN | DEC 4-1 | Mike McKeever Unattached |