| Finals |
| Logan Brown PUR1st | DEC 4-3 | Anthony Biondo Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Tyler Dickenson Unattached3rd | DEC 6-4 | Hafeez Quereshi Unattached4th |
| Marty Smith ILL5th | DEFAULT | David Pisarcik PUR6th |
| Consi Semi |
| Hafeez Quereshi Unattached | DEFAULT | David Pisarcik PUR |
| Tyler Dickenson Unattached | DEC 4-3 | Marty Smith ILL |
| Semifinal |
| Logan Brown PUR | DEC 3-2 | Tyler Dickenson Unattached |
| Anthony Biondo Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-2 | David Pisarcik PUR |
| Consi 4 |
| Hafeez Quereshi Unattached | DEC 5-4 | Chad Friend Unattached |
| Marty Smith ILL | DEC 6-5 | John Schoen NW |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Chad Friend Unattached | PIN 2:58 | Nick Hylton NAVY |
| Hafeez Quereshi Unattached | — | Timothy Lutke Unattached |
| Marty Smith ILL | — | Mario Gonzalez Unattached |
| John Schoen NW | MAJ DEC 16-7 | Charles Carafano NAVY |
| Quarterfinal |
| Logan Brown PUR | DEFAULT | Timothy Lutke Unattached |
| Tyler Dickenson Unattached | DEC 3-2 | Nick Hylton NAVY |
| David Pisarcik PUR | DEC 3-2 | John Schoen NW |
| Anthony Biondo Unattached | DEC 6-3 | Mario Gonzalez Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Chad Friend Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Zach Stolarsky Unattached |
| Hafeez Quereshi Unattached | PIN | Jaron Singley University of the Cumberlands |
| Marty Smith ILL | PIN 5:49 | Gahad Suleiman Cleveland State University |
| Charles Carafano NAVY | DEC 7-3 | Ryan Selley Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Chad Friend Unattached | DEC 8-5 | Kelvin Miller Grand Valley State |
| Hafeez Quereshi Unattached | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Aaron Sullenger Olivet College |
| Marty Smith ILL | DEC 10-5 | Josh Lewis Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Logan Brown PUR | MAJ DEC 18-9 | Ryan Selley Unattached |
| Timothy Lutke Unattached | DEC 5-4 | Charles Carafano NAVY |
| Nick Hylton NAVY | DEC 5-2 | Marty Smith ILL |
| Tyler Dickenson Unattached | DEC 7-1 | Gahad Suleiman Cleveland State University |
| John Schoen NW | PIN 1:43 | Jaron Singley University of the Cumberlands |
| David Pisarcik PUR | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Aaron Sullenger Olivet College |
| Mario Gonzalez Unattached | PIN 3:39 | Zach Stolarsky Unattached |
| Anthony Biondo Unattached | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Chad Friend Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Ryan Selley Unattached | DEC 3-2 | Kelvin Miller Grand Valley State |
| Marty Smith ILL | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Hafeez Quereshi Unattached |
| David Pisarcik PUR | DEC 9-3 | Josh Lewis Unattached |
