| Finals |
| John Laboranti Unattached1st | 5-2 | Rashard Goff Cleveland State University2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Dan Craig Unattached | PIN 1:54 | Dominick Russo RU |
| Tyler Blakely PENN | 10-3 | Fat Kocher Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| John Laboranti Unattached | 3-2 | Patrick Gilmore MD |
| Rashard Goff Cleveland State University | 4-0 | Patrick Walker LIB |
| Consi 4 |
| Fat Kocher Unattached | 3-1 | Ed Bordas RIDER |
| Dan Craig Unattached | 5-4 | Josh Pelletier LIB |
| Tyler Blakely PENN | MED. FORFEIT | Allan Lutterman Unattached |
| Dominick Russo RU | 6-3 | Chris Dempsey PITT-J |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Josh Pelletier LIB | 4-2 | Jim Connors Boston University |
| Allan Lutterman Unattached | 1-0 | Ivan Muller CIT |
| Fat Kocher Unattached | 2-1 | Eric French Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Patrick Gilmore MD | 6-0 | Chris Dempsey PITT-J |
| John Laboranti Unattached | 8-4 | Dan Craig Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Fat Kocher Unattached | 9-4 | Jesse Campbell Ashland University |
| Josh Pelletier LIB | 3-0 | Shane Meighan DREX |
| Dominick Russo RU | 9-3 | Mike Landis NAVY |
| Ivan Muller CIT | 5-2 | Robert Ryhal Unattached |
| Eric French Unattached | 2-1 | Nathan Sharp Mercyhurst University |
| Jim Connors Boston University | 3-1 | Joe Breaux NAVY |
| Allan Lutterman Unattached | 7-3 | Michael Horton Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Ivan Muller CIT | 12-5 | Tyler Jeffries Unattached |
| Michael Horton Unattached | 1-0 | Daniel Estricher Unattached |
| Joe Breaux NAVY | PIN 3:50 | Alex Smythe Unattached |
| Eric French Unattached | 8-0 | Owen Duffy MD |
| Josh Pelletier LIB | 3-0 | Justin Allen LEH |
| Dominick Russo RU | 3-1 | John Simmons DUQ |
| Fat Kocher Unattached | PIN 2:43 | Justin Lathus GALLAUDET |
| Kyle Bilquist Unattached | 4-2 | Oney Snyder COR |
| Round of 16 |
| Dan Craig Unattached | 15-4 | Allan Lutterman Unattached |
| John Laboranti Unattached | PIN 2:31 | Robert Ryhal Unattached |
| Patrick Walker LIB | 8-1 | Mike Landis NAVY |
| Rashard Goff Cleveland State University | 2-1 | Jim Connors Boston University |
| Patrick Gilmore MD | 5-1 | Jesse Campbell Ashland University |
| Ed Bordas RIDER | 4-0 | Jeff Pollard Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Ed Bordas RIDER | PIN 6:35 | Michael Horton Unattached |
| Shane Meighan DREX | 4-3 | Eric French Unattached |
| Jeff Pollard Unattached | 3-0 | Daniel Estricher Unattached |
| Patrick Gilmore MD | 2-0 | Joe Breaux NAVY |
| Jim Connors Boston University | PIN 4:26 | Justin Lathus GALLAUDET |
| Tyler Blakely PENN | 12-4 | Owen Duffy MD |
| John Laboranti Unattached | 9-7 | Dominick Russo RU |
| Nathan Sharp Mercyhurst University | PIN 3:45 | Justin Allen LEH |
| Rashard Goff Cleveland State University | 7-3 | Fat Kocher |
| Round of 64 |
| Dominick Russo RU | 9-3 | Jordan Enck HOF |
| Michael Horton Unattached | PIN 1:54 | Dan Bittner BING |
| Nathan Sharp Mercyhurst University | 5-4 | Aaron Brown CIT |
| Joe Breaux NAVY | 4-1 | Art Garvey BING |
| Ivan Muller CIT | 3-1 | Anthony Driscoll Unattached |
| Fat Kocher Unattached | 3-1 | Sean Dedeyn Unattached |
