| Finals |
| Cayle Byers GMU1st | PIN 4:27 | Hudson Taylor MD2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Josh Ohl Ashland University5th | 23-8 | Corey Waite BING6th |
| Consi Semi |
| Josh Ohl Ashland University | FORFEIT | Martin Porter Unattached |
| Jason Winckel COR | 3-2 | Philip Neese NAVY |
| Semifinal |
| Hudson Taylor MD | 7-0 | John Hall Boston University |
| Cayle Byers GMU | 12-4 | Patrick Walsh PITT-J |
| Consi 4 |
| Philip Neese NAVY | 7-5 | Odie Delaney CIT |
| Corey Waite BING | PIN 1:23 | A.J. Hunte PITT |
| Martin Porter Unattached | 9-3 | Nathan Andrews PSU |
| Jack Callender Unattached | PIN 3:12 | Bobby Gray Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Odie Delaney CIT | PIN 6:18 | Zachary Bennett Unattached |
| Martin Porter Unattached | PIN 1:59 | Mike McKeever Unattached |
| Corey Waite BING | 11-5 | Michael Mutch Unattached |
| Jack Callender Unattached | 5-2 | Charles Carafano NAVY |
| A.J. Hunte PITT | 3-1 | Jacobi Johnson LIB |
| Philip Neese NAVY | 6-2 | Carl Korpi BING |
| Nathan Andrews PSU | 16-0 | Tommy Sitar MD |
| Bobby Gray Unattached | 7-5 | Daren Brown PSU |
| Quarterfinal |
| Cayle Byers GMU | 7-5 | Josh Ohl Ashland University |
| Hudson Taylor MD | PIN 1:10 | Jack Decker PSU |
| John Hall Boston University | MED. FORFEIT | George Kocher Unattached |
| Patrick Walsh PITT-J | 7-5 | Jason Winckel COR |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Jack Callender Unattached | 3-0 | Kenneth Massey Unattached |
| Tommy Sitar MD | PIN 2:58 | Mark Wagner Wagner College |
| Zachary Bennett Unattached | 7-5 | Harry Turner Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| John Hall Boston University | 6-4 | Nathan Andrews PSU |
| Jack Decker PSU | 8-4 | Philip Neese NAVY |
| Patrick Walsh PITT-J | 13-5 | Michael Mutch Unattached |
| Josh Ohl Ashland University | 13-5 | Daren Brown PSU |
| Hudson Taylor MD | PIN 4:31 | Odie Delaney CIT |
| Cayle Byers GMU | 23-7 | Charles Carafano NAVY |
| Round of 32 |
| Daren Brown PSU | 5-3 | Harry Turner Unattached |
| Charles Carafano NAVY | 7-3 | Carl Korpi BING |
| Odie Delaney CIT | PIN 1:26 | Bobby Gray Unattached |
| Jack Decker PSU | PIN 5:30 | Jack Callender Unattached |
| Josh Ohl Ashland University | 11-4 | Zachary Bennett Unattached |
| Nathan Andrews PSU | 11-10 | Corey Waite BING |
| Philip Neese NAVY | 16-1 | Kenneth Massey Unattached |
| Michael Mutch Unattached | 18-7 | Mark Wagner Wagner College |
| Patrick Walsh PITT-J | PIN 1:15 | Tommy Sitar MD |
